ICAEW.com works better with JavaScript enabled.

Boardroom Diversity

Latest articles from the Corporate Governance Community:

Most articles are only available to Corporate Governance Community members. Log in or find out how to join the community.

Board effectiveness review

The 2017 PWC Annual Corporate Directors Survey reported that, “46% of Board members think at least one existing Director needs to be replaced and 21% say two Directors need to be replaced.” How can this be the case, considering the attention focused on enhancing director selection and board evaluation processes in recent years?

How diverse should boards be?

The fourth ICAEW thought piece on corporate governance focuses on diversity, outlining the principal drivers that can help boards set and assess diversity objectives and promote long-term business success.

Widening the business gene pool

Competitive advantage in business is derived from doing old things in new ways as well as doing new things altogether. The same is true in nature; the survival of the fittest, or evolution by natural selection, is about success through the ability to change to meet the changing environment.

Showing 3 of 5 items

Guides and publications

ICAEW

How diverse should boards be?
A ICAEW thought leadership report asking what a truly diverse board looks like - a board that is diverse not just in appearance but in substance. Published in April 2014.

United Kingdom

Class ceilings 
A 2013 report by Equal Approach on the backgrounds, including class, of those holding senior executive positions in the FTSE 100. Gender, age, marital status, route to the top and extra-curricular activities are also considered

The commercial advantage of more women in the boardroom
Study by Women in Retail and Elixirr looking at gender balance within the UK retail sector. Published in June 2016.

Diversity in the boardroom: A guide for business and board-ready candidates in the UK
Report jointly published in April 2010 by the Government Equalities Office (GEO) and the CBI. The report highlights some of the initiatives which exist in the UK to improve boardroom diversity.

Feedback statement: Gender diversity on boards
In October 2011 the FRC announced its decision to amend the UK Corporate Governance Code to strengthen the principle on boardroom diversity which was first introduced into the Code in June 2010. The statement summarises the main points from the consultation responses, the decisions taken by the FRC and the reasons for those decisions.

FTSE Women leaders: Hampton-Alexander review
Initial report of the Hampton-Alexander review into increasing the number of women in senior positions in FTSE 350 companies. This review is looking at ways to ensure to that talented women at the top of business are recognised, promoted and rewarded. The focus of the review is on senior women below the company board.

Gender diversity in the boardroom: reach for the top
Survey report from the CIPD, published in February 2015, highlighting some of the key benefits of having a good gender balance on boards, such as bringing different perspectives to decision-making, reflecting the wider diversity in society and improving business performance. This sample explores HR practitioners’ perspectives on gender diversity in the boardroom and practical strategies for improving female representation at the top of organisations.

Gender diversity on boards: The appointment process and the role of executive search firms
Research report commissioned by the Equality and Human Rights Commission and published by the Cranfield International Centre for Women Leaders in May 2012. The report examines the board appointment process and the role of executive search firms within in with a particular emphasis on initiatives to make boards more gender balanced. The EHRC website also has a guide to Good Practice for Diversity on Boards, updated November 2016.

Mind the gender gap: Are boards rising to the diversity challenge?
Survey report produced by ICAEW and Warren Partners in July 2013 highlighting trends and opinion.

Report into the diversity of UK Boards (Parker Review)
Findings of a review carried out by EY into the diversity of boards in FTSE 100 companies, published in November 2016. It found that the boardrooms of Britain’s leading companies do not reflect the ethnic diversity of either the UK or the stakeholders that they seek to engage and represent. Ethnic minority representation across the FTSE 100 and 250 is disproportionately low and the report makes recommendations for the long-term.

Report on board effectiveness: Highlighting best practice, encouraging progress
In September 2011 the Association of British Insurers (ABI) published its report on board effectiveness. The report focuses on three key issues, with one being boardroom diversity, and aims to 'help companies to better understand the views of institutional investors on effective boardroom performance'. The report includes the results of analysis of FTSE 350 annual reports to examine what companies are doing to improve diversity in their boardrooms and across their whole organisations.

Tyson report on the recruitment and development of non-executive directors
Report from a group of business leaders following up on recommendations from the Higgs report. The report looks at how 'companies might draw on broader pools of talent with varied and complementary skills, experiences and perspectives to enhance board effectiveness'. The report was published by the London Business School in 2003.

Women in the City
Report published in April 2010 by the Treasury Select Committee following an inquiry into the representation of women at senior levels within large financial institutions in the UK. You can also access responses to the report from the UK Government and the Equalities and Human Rights Commission

Women in finance: A springboard to corporate board positions?
This report, commissioned by ACCA and the Economic & Social Research Council and published by ACCA in December 2012, explores the role of a financial background or qualification in FTSE 100 board appointments for women. The report was announced in the press release Finance background helps women get boardroom positions.

Women in finance charter
The charter sets out the commitment of HM Treasury and signatory firms to work together to build a more balanced and fair finance industry. It was drawn up in March 2016, based on the findings of a review by the CEO of Virgin Money and pledges to implement four key industry actions. There is also a timeline of the Charter's achievements in its first year.

Women in Financial Services 2016
Report by management consulting firm Oliver Wyman on gender diversity in the global financial services industry. The report was announced in the press release Financial services industry lagging in unleashing female leadership potential on June 13 2016. 

Women on Boards Reports
Government hub page for reports relating to Lord Davies of Anersoch's Women on Boards review (published 2011), including the annual review and 5 year summary. 

Women on boards: benchmarking early adopters of the Corporate Governance Code 2012
Interim report published by Cranfield School of Management in November 2012 which monitors the progress of FTSE 100 companies on the diversity amendment made to the UK Corporate Governance Code and provides a benchmark of best practice based on early adopters of the revised Code.

Women on Boards: A Life Sciences' Perspective (RSA)
A survey of senior executives in the UK Life Sciences industry commissioned by the RSA and published in 2012, which provides data on the gender imbalance in the boardrooms of UK Life Sciences companies and explores what might be done to improve the situation. The study also aims to find out whether the Life Sciences industry is a more favourable environment for women to progress to the most senior positions. 

International

2013 Chief Executive Study: Women CEOs of the last 10 years
Strategy&'s annual Chief Executive Study examines CEO successions and success among the world’s top 2,500 public companies. The 2013 edition focused particularly on women CEOs between 2004-2013, highlighting a few key differences between male and female CEOs.

Breaking the glass ceiling: Women in the boardroom
The third 2013 edition of this report by Paul Hastings LLP provides updates to jurisdictions with notable developments over the past 12 months, as well as five new jurisdictions: Austria, Denmark, Finland, India and Sweden. It aims to provide a comprehensive, global survey of how different countries are addressing the issue of gender parity on corporate boards. 

The business case for women's economic empowerment: an integrated framework
Study by the Oak Foundation, the International Center for Research on Women and Dalberg Global Development Advisors looking at corporate-funded women’s economic empowerment programs. Includes an integrated framework that the private sector can adopt to increase return on investment and enhance women’s economic advancement.

Consultation on gender imbalance in corporate boards in the EU 
Access reference documents and replies to the EU consultation on initiatives to improve the gender balance on the boards of listed companies. The consultation closed in May 2012.

Diverse abilities: Leveraging all abilities to build high-performing organizations
Report from the first EY Diverse Abilities Leadership Summit, in December 2014, where company leaders discussed new thinking and practices to help leverage diverse abilities to create high-performing organisations. The report, published in May 2016, captures some of the key ideas and themes that emerged from the summit.

Diversity drives diversity: From the boardroom to the C-suite
A 2013 Ernst & Young report focusing on diversity in boardrooms of US companies at the time of their 2013 annual meetings, with some comparisons of diversity across industry sectors. It also explores the impact female directors and leaders are having on diversity.

European Women on Boards studies 
The EWoB studies on Gender Diversity on European Boards are carried out with key stakeholders (companies, women board candidates, etc), with a view to assess the situation and to contribute to making progress in terms of women’s participation in decision-making. The study provides quantitative data, and an analysis and recommendations. Realising Europe’s potential: progress and challenges (April 2016) examines the participation of women directors on the boards of the STOXX 600 companies between 2011 and 2015. The study also looks at other related topics such as the inclusion of women directors and board committees and the promotion of women into board leadership position. Realising Europe’s Potential: Experiences and Best Practices (July 2016) confirms the findings of EWoB’s first study, acknowledging that the “representation of female directors on boards of the largest European listed companies has almost doubled in the last five years”, while at the same time highlighting the need for organisations to measure gender diversity, established targets and actively monitor progress.

Executive remuneration in Australia
A report published in January 2010 by the Australian Productivity Commission. Chapter 6 discusses the role of the board and includes a section on attracting talented and experienced candidates. The report provides an insight into the current situation of female under-representation on boards and looks at measures to improve gender diversity in boardrooms.

Women in business 2016: Turning promise into practice
International business report from Grant Thornton, published in 2016, examining why a third of businesses still have no women at senior management level. It examines diversity in leadership in a number of countries around the world, the types of roles occupied by women and the qualities required for leadership. It also offers some recommendations for improving gender diversity in leadership.

Women in the boardroom: A global perspective
The fourth edition of this biennial report, last published in 2015 by the Deloitte Global Centre for Corporate Governance, gives an overview of current initiatives around the world, both legal and regulatory, to increase the number of women serving on corporate boards.

Women matter
Series of reports regularly published by McKinsey Global Institute since 2007. The reports in this series explore how gender diversity and leadership styles typically adopted by women leaders impact on company performance and report on developments to increase female representation in senior positions.

Women on board: the Norwegian experience
Report published in 2010 by the German political foundation Friedrich-Ebert-Stiftung which documents the introduction of a quota for female board representation in Norway. The report looks at how the quota came into being and which changes it has set in motion since its introduction in 2003.

Women on boards: Commission proposes 40% objective
This collection of reports and factsheets including country specific information was published by the European Commission in November 2012 in support of its proposed legislation to establish a 40% quota for female board members in publicly listed companies.

Women on corporate boards: Lessons from the consumer sector
Survey carried out by the consumer sector recruitment firm Nigel Wright which is based on the opinions of 'over 100 senior executives from a range of consumer sector businesses in Europe on the issue of gender diversity on corporate boards'. The survey was carried out in June and July 2011.

Indexes, statistics and regular surveys.

A joint report on UK Boardroom diversity
A joint BDO and Quoted Companies Alliance annual board review, looking at the board composition of all UK listed companies and analysing underlying trends. 2nd edition published 2016.

2014 Board practices report: Perspectives from the boardroom
A joint Deloitte and Society of Corporate Secretaries and Governance Professionals report, presenting results from a survey of the Society's membership. The survey covered a number of board governance areas, including board composition. Since the previous 2012 survey gender and ethnicity diversity on boards has gradually improved, but there appears to be a standstill on adding younger board members.

Boardroom Diversity Index (Australia)
This annual survey, published by Women on Boards since 2010, is the 'first comprehensive publicly available data measuring female participation on the boards of organisations in Australia'.

The Female FTSE Index & Reports
Annual benchmarking report by the Global Centre for Gender and Leadership which has been published since 1999 and includes details of the number of female non-executive directors on the corporate boards of the UK's top 100 companies.

UK Board Index: Current board trends and practices at major UK companies
Comprehensive review of governance practice in the largest 150 companies in the FTSE rankings, published by Spencer Stuart in 2016, indicating of the state of boardroom health during 2015-16. The report places particular importance on the theme of diversity – in addition to gender and nationality, the dimensions of age and ethnicity are explored.

Women in Finance Survey 2017
Survey being compiled by Virgin Money in association with HM Treasury looking at gender diversity in the financial services sector. The 2016 Ghadia Report - Empowering Productivity: Harnessing the Talents of Women in Financial Services is also available to download.

Women on corpoarte boards globally
Annual statistics on female board representation across the globe published by Catalyst.

Organisations and networks

The 30% Club
A group of chairmen and organisations committed to bringing more women onto UK corporate boards. The initiative aims to have at least 30% women on UK plc boards within five years.

European Professional Women's Network
Includes a Women on Boards section with articles, reports and a biannual Board Women Monitor.

Global Board Ready Women (GBRW)
In December 2012 the European Business Schools/Women on Board Initiative launched a searchable database of board ready women as reported in this press release by the European Foundation for Management Development (EFMD). The database and a member forum are administered by the Financial Times Non-Executive Directors’ Club on LinkedIn.

The Mentoring Foundation
The foundation develops and manages the FTSE 100 Cross-Company Mentoring Programme, a mentoring programme for senior women executives who are matched with senior business leaders to develop and fulfil their potential.

OUT-standing in Business
Professional network for LGBT executives. The network publishes a Top 50 List of LGBT role models and leaders in business in conjunction with the Financial Times.

Professional Boards Forum
Programme bringing together leading chairmen and outstanding women board candidates for board opportunities. The Forum publishes regularly updated figures of female directors appointed to UK corporate boards.

Women for Boards
Scheme sponsored by MWM Consulting, BP and a number of senior business women aiming to increase the number of high-quality women on the boards of FTSE 250 and FTSE 350 companies through pairing potential candidates with mentors.

See also

eBooks

The Library provides full text access to a selection of key business and reference eBooks from leading publishers. eBooks are available to logged-in ICAEW members, ACA students and other entitled users. If you are unable to access an eBook, please see our Help and support advice or contact library@icaew.com.

Ideas for leaders collection

A collection of the latest global management and business thinking summarised into straight forward and understandable language. This collection comes in 7 volumes covering the following: Volume 1: Strategic leadership; Volume 2: Corporate culture and performance; Volume 3: Innovation & entrepreneurship; Volume 4: Strategy and operations; Volume 5: Leaders behaviour and development; Volume 6: Networks & communications; Volume 7: Customer focus; Volume 8: Governance, risk and corporate social responsibility.

It's not a glass ceiling, it's a sticky floor: free yourself from the hidden behaviours sabotaging your career success

Aims to build career development skills for women in business. Includes chapters on work-life balance, communication skills, and self-confidence.

Woman's place is in the boardroom, A

The book makes the case for promoting women to the board of directors. It includes interviews and case studies of women in business to support the argument that board diversity creates more value for shareholders.

Woman's place is in the boardroom, A: the roadmap

Guide to implementing organizational change to improve gender equality. It is especially concerned with establishing women on the board of directors.

Showing 4 of 6 items

Terms of use: You are permitted to access, download, copy, or print out content from eBooks for your own research or study only, subject to the terms of use set by our suppliers and any restrictions imposed by individual publishers. Please see individual supplier pages for full terms of use.

Women in leadership: Time for more

This article shares insights, advice and questions from participants in the Women's Accounting Leadership Series, about moving up in accounting and finance. Topics discussed include barriers to career advancement among women in finance and accounting, what women can do to create a more inclusive workplace environment such as seeking male and female colleagues as mentors and serving as a mentor to male colleagues, and skills required to rise to the top.

Women in leadership: Time for more

This article shares insights, advice and questions from participants in the Women's Accounting Leadership Series, about moving up in accounting and finance. Topics discussed include barriers to career advancement among women in finance and accounting, what women can do to create a more inclusive workplace environment such as seeking male and female colleagues as mentors and serving as a mentor to male colleagues, and skills required to rise to the top.

Deviating from traditional career paths can strengthen firmwide diversity

Article on diversity and inclusion in accounting firms, featuring a case study from Frazier & Deeter. Putting employees together in new projects where they can help shape team culture from the start or developing 'affinity groups' are ways to ensure that potential partners from diverse backgrounds have opportunities to develop supportive relationships.

Showing 3 of 41 items

Articles and books in the Library collection

Selected articles and books

This is a selection of articles and books in our print collection which contain information on boardroom diversity – click on the links to see our catalogue record and holdings for each item. Please contact us if you would like to borrow a book or request a copy of an article.

If women are the solution, what is the problem?
Economia, No.36. March 2015. pp.66-67.
The debate about gender diversity on corporate boards is mostly about how to get more women on boards: there is very little discussion about why the number should be increased. But boards without female members have successfully run many companies for many years and company failure is rarely, if ever, ascribed to board gender balance. What problem is this intervention designed to address?

Across the Board?
Economia,  No.36.  March 2015.  pp.41-44.
Article looks at whether getting more women into the top level of companies' governance should be done, and which countries are doing it best. The question of women on company boards - how many to have, and how to get them there - has been one of the key business debates of the decade. Now, according to Thomson Reuters, more than half of corporate boards have a least a 10% female membership. A 2014 study from Credit Suisse concludes board diversity has increased in almost every country, reaching 12.7% globally. And among companies in the MSCI World stock market index, women currently hold 17.3% of all directorships. Looks at quotas in US, Brazil, UK, Norway, South Africa, China and Japan.

Beauty queen: inside the reign of Avon's Andrea Jung 
D.Himsel (Palgrave Macmillan, 2014, 228 pages)
Former Avon vice president Deborah Himsel uses Andrea Jung's story as a case study for two timeless leadership questions: What makes great leaders great? And what makes them fail? Using interviews with other CEOs and leadership experts, she explores the unique challenges Jung faced as a female Fortune 500 CEO.

Women on board: insider secrets to getting on a board and succeeding as a director  
N.Calderon (Quotation Media, 2014, 327 pages)
Includes chapters: the status quo; getting a seat at the table; contributing from day one; board work; succeeding as a director and creating visionary boards; a call to action; are you ready to make a difference?; and additional insights and resources for today's director.

Views from some of the world's top female accountants 
International Accounting Bulletin, March 2014, pp.8-10 
Mentoring women and female role models within the business are some of the most frequently suggested measures to encourage women to take leadership roles. The author speaks to some of the profession's prominent and successful role models about their experience, advice and views of gender diversity.

Find more articles and books

To find out how you can borrow books from the Library please see our guide to book loans. You can obtain copies of articles or extracts of books and reports by post, fax or email through our document supply service.

The Chartered Accountants’ Trust for Education and Research, a registered charity, owns the library and maintains and operates it for ICAEW.