As AI adoption continues to outpace governance and competence, ICAEW’s annual ethics event probes fundamental questions around the technology’s influence on trust.
Key takeaways
- Ethics and AI: as AI develops rapidly and businesses rush to adopt it, new ethical dilemmas for business are created. These include overreliance on AI tools, unclear outputs and market concentration, according to Chair of the International Ethics Standards Board for Accountants (IESBA), Gabriela Figueiredo Dias.
- Developing AI assurance: experts such as Professor Edward Harcourt, philosopher and Director of the Institute for Ethics in AI at the University of Oxford, has stressed the need for the development of a strong AI assurance profession, as a survey of 118 financial institutions found that 46% didn’t understand the AI products they invested in.
- Workforce implications of technology adoption: AI adoption is more than a technology issue, according to experts at ICAEW’s Global Ethics Day Event on 23 October; it also impacts talent and processes, data security and even brand reputation.
The rapid development of artificial intelligence (AI) requires accountants to consider ethics through a new lens and assess where we may need to recalibrate our approach.
That was the opening message at “Trust in the Digital Age,” ICAEW’s recent event to mark Global Ethics Day. The event took stock of AI’s impacts upon ethics in the profession, with ICAEW Vice President Neil Cutting setting the tone.
While technology can enhance controls and risk management, Cutting stressed, it cannot replace ethical responsibility. Accountants should not simply ask whether technology can produce an answer. They must ask: is the output reliable? Do we understand how our tool has reached its conclusions? And who is accountable for its decisions?
“These are fundamental ethical questions,” Cutting said. “As technology grows more sophisticated, human judgement becomes more, not less, important.”
In a keynote address, Gabriela Figueiredo Dias, Chair of the International Ethics Standards Board for Accountants (IESBA), said that AI’s challenge to accountancy comes in three parts:
- Business models: AI’s ability to compress hours – and potentially fees – may lead to an overreliance on automated tools and undermine professional judgement.
- Opaque outcomes: with adoption outpacing competence and governance, professionals are still accountable for outputs they may struggle to fully explain.
- Concentration: the speed and scale with which firms are getting increasingly tied between large auditors and AI providers has implications for market concentration, due care and independence that merit close monitoring.
While IESBA is not currently planning to issue new professional standards for AI, Dias noted that it published special guidance on emerging technologies in July and will release further guidance on generative and agentic AI early next year.
AI adoption is racing ahead – without much understanding
Professor Edward Harcourt, philosopher and Director of the Institute for Ethics in AI at the University of Oxford, pointed out that in a recent survey of 118 financial institutions, 46% said they didn’t fully understand the AI products they had invested in.
“That’s one reason why developing an AI assurance profession is so super-important,” he said, adding: “the central ethical task for any profession is to know your workflows inside out, know where you need to leave humans in the loop and make sure you train even AI natives with the ethics and codes of conduct that have served you so well.”
A panel of senior figures at Deloitte, “AI and the Future of Trust” opened with a suggestion from Partner and session chair Scott Campbell that stakeholders are “sprinting in the fog” on AI. In that light, AI Workforce Transformation Lead Davinder Kang warned that the impacts of AI deployment upon employees are a major ethical consideration. “You can mandate access, but you can’t mandate confidence,” she said. “Do your people know what these tools do? Do they understand the limitations?”
Picking up on the workforce implications of AI adoption, Perrine Masset, Partner for AI Growth Enabled Transformation, noted: “AI adoption should not be treated simply as a technology problem. It reshapes organisations, talent and processes, requiring a multidisciplinary approach that equips people to adopt it positively.”
Partner and UK Lead for Trustworthy AI Tom Millar explored reputational risks, drawing on a recent event he attended on AI adoption. “One big topic was brand damage,” he said. “AI agents making mistakes that people make all the time is giving firms much more significant bad publicity than years’ worth of human errors.”
ICAEW Director of Regulatory Policy Sophie Wales looked at how AI usage affects due diligence around confidentiality. For example: “you may have locked down some of your data so certain staff can’t access it. But what if your digital tool can access everything and it uses locked-down data from one part of your organisation to advise another part? You may find that the tool has breached the control you’ve put in place, because it knows more than it should.”
Stepping back from AI to consider broader business-critical issues, Vernon Dennis, Partner at law firm Howard Kennedy, argued that a director’s duty under the 2006 Companies Act – to promote the success of their business – requires a materiality assessment of a range of environmental, social and governance (ESG) issues. Any non-financial ESG issue that materially affects a business ultimately has a financial impact and is therefore relevant to the company’s sustainability and long-term success.
IESBA Board Member David Wray then outlined the organisation’s wide-ranging Role of the CFO initiative. Launched last year, the project is taking a deep dive into the fast-changing nature of the CFO’s role, amid a host of new ethical pressures, including the rise of AI. Wray noted that CFOs are calling for more support on ethical matters, “but not in the form of a PDF.” As such, IESBA is engaging with several accounting bodies to explore innovative, tech-driven guidance that will provide real-time support.
Corrupting barrel
The following session examined factors that shape the ethics behind employees’ actions at work. Entitled “Why Do Good People Sometimes Make Poor Decisions?,” the talk harnessed lessons from real-world case studies, presented by Wies Wagenaar, Ethics and Business Conduct Leader at PwC Netherlands, and Wieke Scholten PhD, Owner at behavioral risk specialists BR Insights.
Delegates heard that any setting in which people work together can spawn ethical lapses, as a result of emergent behavioural patterns. In that sense, issues stem not from “bad apples,” but the far wider problem of a corrupting barrel.
In Wagenaar and Scholten’s assessment, the end products of employees’ behaviours arise from “organisational context,” comprised of three levels, like those of a tree:
- Roots: behavioural drivers, such as the organisation’s formal structure (governance, policy and procedures), informal structure (unwritten rules, social norms and assumptions) and leadership style (how senior figures set examples).
- Trunk: behavioural patterns that emerge from those roots, affecting collaboration, communication, decision making and how people respond to mistakes.
- Branches: the ultimate impacts of those patterns upon key business outcomes, such as quality, performance and client satisfaction.
"Roots" factors that can drive unethical behaviours include unfeasible targets or timeframes, authoritarian and risk-focused leadership, user-unfriendly procedures and an overreliance on controls rather than judgement.
Under pressure, the experts warned, 10-12% of staff would cut corners in some way. So, while tone from the top is valuable, it is much more important to establish sound ethical conditions within the more local climates of the teams that people work in every day, instilling good practice at roots level.
That was the opening message at “Trust in the Digital Age,” ICAEW’s recent event to mark Global Ethics Day. The event took stock of AI’s impacts upon ethics in the profession, with ICAEW Vice President Neil Cutting setting the tone.
While technology can enhance controls and risk management, Cutting stressed, it cannot replace ethical responsibility. Accountants should not simply ask whether technology can produce an answer. They must ask: is the output reliable? Do we understand how our tool has reached its conclusions? And who is accountable for its decisions?
“These are fundamental ethical questions,” Cutting said. “As technology grows more sophisticated, human judgement becomes more, not less, important.”
In a keynote address, Gabriela Figueiredo Dias, Chair of the International Ethics Standards Board for Accountants (IESBA), said that AI’s challenge to accountancy comes in three parts:
- Business models: AI’s ability to compress hours – and potentially fees – may lead to an overreliance on automated tools and undermine professional judgement.
- Opaque outcomes: with adoption outpacing competence and governance, professionals are still accountable for outputs they may struggle to fully explain.
- Concentration: the speed and scale with which firms are getting increasingly tied between large auditors and AI providers has implications for market concentration, due care and independence that merit close monitoring.
While IESBA is not currently planning to issue new professional standards for AI, Dias noted that it published special guidance on emerging technologies in July and will release further guidance on generative and agentic AI early next year.
Standards for sustainability assurance
Wray returned to the podium to provide delegates with a timely reminder that IESBA’s International Ethics Standards for Sustainability Assurance (IESSA) will take effect on 15 December. Designed to promote truthfulness in the reporting of sustainability-related information, and to safeguard independence in the analysis of that data, IESSA will straddle all the different sustainability reporting regimes in force around the world, affecting preparers and auditors alike. Importantly, Wray noted, “IESBA Sustainability Standards boost defences against greenwashing and provide a valuable playbook for reporters’ and auditors’ use of external experts.”
The session also featured an update on developments in modern slavery legislation.
Robert Barrington, Professor of Anti-Corruption Practice in the University of Sussex's Centre for the Study of Corruption, brought some grim tidings. In the past decade, the UK has slipped “markedly” on all major indices of corruption and integrity, including Transparency International’s Corruption Perceptions Index, where it has moved from 82% to 70%: a decline second only to that of Belarus.
In Barrington’s view, shaped by research for his new book “Corrupted Kingdom,” accountancy and the other professional services are vital components of a “national integrity system” for defending the UK against corruption. As such, they must always prioritise serving the public interest – and at times do better at resisting influences that can draw them into being used as professional enablers of corruption. “We’ve got to get this right,” Barrington said. “If we don’t, our slide on the Index will only go downwards.”