ICAEW.com works better with JavaScript enabled.
Exclusive

Portfolio Careers Community

Solo or collective? Finding the portfolio route that fits you

Author: Daniella Wainwright, founder of Wainwright Consulting and ICAEW’s Subject Matter Expert for Portfolio Careers

Published: 16 Nov 2026

Exclusive content
Access to our exclusive resources is for specific groups of students, users, subscribers and members.

Going portfolio doesn’t have to mean going it alone. Daniella Wainwright, founder of Wainwright Consulting and ICAEW’s Subject Matter Expert for Portfolio Careers, sets out the main routes into fractional CFO and FD work, what each one really costs and how to choose.

More routes than you think

When I talk to finance leaders considering a portfolio career, most don’t realise there’s more than one way to do it. They picture a lone FD building a client list from scratch, or a big national network, and that’s where the picture ends.

In fact, there’s a whole spectrum. At our recent Portfolio Careers Community webinar, I was joined by two fractional CFOs who’d taken very different paths: one built an independent portfolio over several years, and the other draws on the brand and reach of an established network. There’s no single right route, only the one that fits you.

I’ve seen this from both sides. I started out as a solo part-time FD in 2020, and I’ve since built Wainwright Consulting into my own small, local network of associate FDs across Yorkshire. I also train finance leaders who want to go it alone.

Route one: going it alone

This is the route I took. You keep your full day rate, but I think the bigger prize is control: over your clients, your offer, your rate, your week and your brand.

The trade-offs are real, though.

  • It can be lonely. You’ll work closely with client teams, but without colleagues who do what you do.
  • Everything is on you. Contracts, insurance, your practising certificate, AML supervision and invoicing.
  • So is finding the work. Networking, LinkedIn and sales conversations, especially at the start.

A rule of thumb: keep one day a week free of client work for business development and admin. In this world, four chargeable days is a full week.

Route two: joining a collective

Here you’re subcontracted to serve a network’s clients, usually under their brand. There are large national fractional CFO networks as well as smaller regional and specialist groups.

The benefits are clear. A recognised brand can reassure a business owner in a first meeting, and there’s infrastructure behind you and a ready-made group of peers. If the network has a steady flow of clients, you may get going faster.

The cost is a share of your day rate, typically between 20% and 40%. On an £800 day rate, 30% is £240 a day, or more than £33,000 a year across a three-day week. That can be excellent value, or not. It depends on what you get back.

Experiences vary. Some FDs do very little business development, while others still attend sales meetings and lean on their own contacts to win clients. A full portfolio can take longer to arrive than people expect, depending on how many FDs are already waiting and how well your experience matches the clients coming in. You may also have less say over methods, branding and which clients you take on.

For the right person, though, it’s exactly right. If you have young children or caring responsibilities, hobbies you want to make space for, or you really can’t face networking and marketing yourself, having help finding the work can suit you perfectly.

If you’re considering a network, ask:

  1. What share of my day rate do you take, and does it change if I bring the client?
  2. How much work is introduced, and how much am I expected to find myself?
  3. How many FDs are already waiting for work in my area or sector?
  4. Can I speak to two or three current associates?
  5. Can I keep my own clients, and what are the notice terms?

Route three: go solo, with help on the hard bits

There’s a middle ground that doesn’t get talked about enough: go it alone, keeping your independence and your full rate, but get help with the parts you find hardest.

For most finance leaders, that’s business development. Selling rarely comes naturally after a career in finance, but it is learnable. I surprised myself by enjoying it once I’d made one simple reframe: you’re not really selling, you’re helping a business owner reach their business and life goals.

Help can come from a mentor, a business coach, a peer group such as the ICAEW Portfolio Careers Community, or structured training on setting up and winning work. As finance people, we don’t love risk, and anything that shortens the learning curve de-risks the move.

How to choose your route

Ask yourself four honest questions:

  • How much does control matter to me?
  • How comfortable am I with networking and selling, and am I willing to learn?
  • How much do I value having colleagues around me?
  • What would I take home after a network’s share, and is that enough?

As a rough guide: go solo if control matters most and you’re willing to build your business development skills. It also helps to have a longer financial runway, after redundancy for example, as it can take a while to win your first clients. Join a network if introductions and community matter more to you than the share of rate and control you give up. Take the middle road if you want your independence, with support while you make the move.

Daniella (Dani) Wainwright FCA is ICAEW’s Subject Matter Expert for Portfolio Careers and founder of Wainwright Consulting, which supports ambitious SMEs across Yorkshire with part-time FDs. She also helps finance leaders build their own portfolio careers through resources for aspiring portfolio FDs and her newsletter, The Fractional Formula. Connect with Dani on LinkedIn.

*the views expressed are the author’s and not ICAEW’s

Open AddCPD icon