The Institute’s quality assurance team visited 401 firms and reviewed work on 790 audits in the year which were selected as those likely to be the firms’ most complex or challenging audits.
Sixty-seven per cent of those audits were rated as either good or generally acceptable. While this was a decrease on 2023 ratings (71%), the average audit quality is likely to be higher given the targeted file selection. The percentage of audits requiring significant improvements remained relatively steady at 10%.
Audit quality cannot be directly compared year-on-year because – except for the Big Four firms – different audit firms are visited each year as they are reviewed on longer cycles.
Among the Big Four, 90% of audits were good or generally acceptable, and only one audit required significant improvement.
Where audits were found to require significant improvement, this did not necessarily mean the audit opinion was incorrect.
Nick Reynolds, ICAEW Professional Standards Head of Audit, said: "Though we can’t compare results year-on-year, the majority of audits we reviewed continued to remain good or generally acceptable. Our reviewers select the most complex files so overall, audit quality is likely to be higher.
“Although we see a lot of good audit work across our wide range of registered firms, we know that some continue to struggle due to a variety of factors including inability to attract and retain good audit staff. Larger firms fare better in the recruitment market, with stronger overall audit quality results.
“We’ll continue to support our firms to help them build and maintain high standards, including with the release of our latest training film, Crossing the Line.”
ICAEW will also be hosting a series of free webinars to explore the issues and insights arising from the monitoring visits in more detail.
The report also highlights the efforts made by firms to enhance their quality management procedures in line with ISQM 1 requirements. Many firms have invested considerable time and resources in the implementation of a quality management system over the past three years, ICAEW said.
ICAEW registers about 2,000 firms to conduct audit work. It plays a significant role in monitoring the quality of non-Public Interest Entity (PIE) audit work and is the largest recognised supervisory body in the UK.
ENDS
Notes to editors
- The full report is available here.
Our role as an improvement regulator
Our mission as an improvement regulator is to strengthen trust in ICAEW Chartered Accountants and firms. We do this by enabling, evaluating and enforcing the highest standards in the profession.
ICAEW’s regulatory and conduct roles are separated from ICAEW’s other activities so that we can monitor, support or take steps to ensure change if standards are not met. These roles are carried out by the Professional Standards Department (PSD) and overseen by the ICAEW Regulatory Board (IRB).
Our role is to:
authorise ICAEW firms, members and affiliates to undertake work regulated by law: audit, local audit, investment business, insolvency and probate;
support the highest professional standards in general accountancy practice through our Practice Assurance scheme;
provide robust anti-money laundering supervision and monitoring;
monitor ICAEW firms and insolvency practitioners to ensure they operate correctly and to the highest standards;
investigate complaints and hold ICAEW firms and members to account where they fall short of standards;
respond and comment on proposed changes to the law and regulation; and
educate through guidance and advice to help stakeholders comply with laws, regulations and professional standards.
Contact ICAEW media office:
About ICAEW
Chartered accountants are talented, ethical and committed professionals. ICAEW represents more than 208,000 members and students around the world.
Founded in 1880, ICAEW has a long history of serving the public interest and we continue to work with governments, regulators and business leaders globally. And, as a world-leading improvement regulator, we supervise and monitor around 12,000 firms, holding them, and all ICAEW members and students, to the highest standards of professional competency and conduct.
We promote inclusivity, diversity and fairness and we give talented professionals the skills and values they need to build resilient businesses, economies and societies, while ensuring our planet’s resources are managed sustainably.
ICAEW is the first major professional body to be carbon neutral, demonstrating our commitment to tackle climate change and supporting UN Sustainable Development Goal 13.
ICAEW is a founding member of Chartered Accountants Worldwide (CAW), a global family that connects more than 1.8m chartered accountants and students in more than 190 countries. Together, we support, develop and promote the role of chartered accountants as trusted business leaders, difference makers and advisers.
We believe that chartered accountancy can be a force for positive change. By sharing our insight, expertise and understanding we can help to create sustainable economies and a better future for all.