ICAEW.com works better with JavaScript enabled.
Exclusive

Corporate Governance Community

UK shareholder activism: five ways boards can prepare

Author: Nick Laugier, Head of Europe, Georgeson, and Elliot Whittingham, Business Development Director – Investor Engagement, Computershare

Published: 17 Nov 2026

Exclusive content
Access to our exclusive resources is for specific groups of students, users, members and subscribers.

Understanding shareholder concerns before a campaign becomes public gives boards more time to respond. Whilst traditional activist campaigns continued during 2026, companies and their boards also faced new activist pressure this year, including: challenges to takeover situations, investment trust campaigns and shareholder demands for greater representation in the boardroom.

For directors, company secretaries and governance professionals, these developments highlight the value of knowing who holds voting influence and how investors make decisions. Preparation connects the following three tasks: understanding shareholders, maintaining dialogue and having a response plan ready before a formal challenge arrives.

Three trends shaping shareholder activism in the UK so far this year

  1. Investment trust campaigns. Asset management firm Saba Capital continued its campaign across UK investment trusts this year. The campaign focused on discounts to net asset value, overall performance and board accountability. These activism campaigns illustrate how activists combine public communications, investor outreach and governance arguments to seek institutional and retail shareholder support.
  2. Challenges to takeover terms. Shareholders may also challenge transaction terms when they believe boards accepted an inadequate valuation for a takeover. This can happen when there were instances of strong takeover activity and limited new listings. In several situations, long-only institutional investors publicly opposed recommended transactions. Their objections highlighted the importance of companies explaining long-term value alongside the headline premium.
  3. Requests for board representation. We saw a growing willingness among shareholders, where they held a sizable stake in companies and were seeking direct influence in the boardroom. Rather than advocating from the sidelines, a number of investors sought board representation to influence governance and strategy through board appointments. These requests underline the importance of understanding investor concerns and maintaining dialogue throughout the year. There is an expectation that boards should remain responsive to their shareholders.

Together, these developments highlight an important shift. Shareholder activism is becoming more varied, public and closely connected to governance than at any point in recent years.

As a result, companies need to understand shareholder support whilst boards need to understand where this support sits, what informs it and how it may change.

Why proxy advisors matter

Proxy advisors do more than provide annual general meeting (AGM) voting recommendations. Their research can also inform institutional investors’ assessments of activist campaigns. Institutional Shareholder Services (ISS) and Glass Lewis provide research, governance analysis and voting infrastructure to support investors’ stewardship activities.

Routine AGM analysis typically covers director independence, diversity and attendance, as well as other governance matters. They also assess proposed board candidates and whether changes are likely to create long-term shareholder value.

One common misconception is that institutional investors simply follow standard proxy voting policies. In reality, many investors apply customised voting frameworks that reflect their own governance philosophies and stewardship priorities. Understanding who owns your shares, and how those investors make decisions, remains just as important as understanding proxy advisor policies.

For boards facing a potential activist campaign, engagement with proxy advisors should be viewed as critical, alongside shareholder outreach and vote forecasting.

Contested situations bring broader questions to the company about financial performance, responsiveness to shareholders and the credibility of each side’s proposals.

Proxy advisors also assess proposed board candidates and whether changes are likely to create long-term shareholder value.

Their recommendations are one part of the picture. Many institutional investors use customised voting frameworks that reflect their own governance principles and stewardship priorities. Understanding those frameworks matters as much as understanding proxy advisor policies. Engagement with advisors therefore sits alongside shareholder outreach and vote forecasting when companies prepare for a campaign.

This balance between proxy advisor research and investors’ own policies is also evolving as changes in advisory services and voting arrangements reshape the wider voting landscape.

A requisition notice leaves limited time

A requisition notice, or a formal request for a general meeting, can leave boards with a short period to assess the challenge and prepare their response. Under the Companies Act 2006, shareholders holding at least 5% of voting rights can formally requisition a general meeting. Within 21 days of receiving a valid requisition, the board must convene the meeting.

The company must therefore begin preparations quickly. Early board preparation includes assessing the validity of the request, understanding the proposed resolutions and assembling advisors. The company also develops its response, reviews likely shareholder voting behaviour and prepares its defence circular, a formal document created by the company that sets out the board’s response to the activist’s proposals, its voting recommendations and the reasons behind them.

Once the meeting notice is published, attention turns to briefing institutional investors, engaging proxy advisors and assessing voting intentions. Vote forecasting becomes particularly important as it helps to identify potential opposition, voting errors and missing votes while there is still time to intervene.

The meeting concludes the formal process. The most successful defence campaigns are rarely won in the meeting room, however. They are won through preparation, shareholder engagement and effective communication during the preceding months.

A response plan that anticipates a shareholder demand and is prepared before it arrives, gives boards more time to focus on the issues raised within the requisition notice.

Five ways boards can prepare

1. Understand beneficial ownership and voting influence

Legal ownership and voting influence do not always sit in the same place.

Regular shareholder analysis helps boards understand beneficial ownership, concentrations of voting power and changes in the shareholder base. It can also identify influential investors and groups of shareholders whose voting positions may align.

2. Analyse voting behaviour

Historical turnout, voting patterns and areas of dissent help explain how shareholders may respond to governance, remuneration or strategic proposals.

This analysis can identify concerns that may attract wider support during a campaign. Voting projections also help boards assess where further engagement may be useful.

3. Review corporate governance

Director independence, tenure and succession planning, as well as committee composition and diversity, and executive remuneration can all become subjects of shareholder scrutiny.

Regular reviews help boards understand potential concerns before a campaign brings them into public discussion. Even issues that appear minor in isolation can become more prominent in a contested situation.

4. Maintain shareholder dialogue

Activists are often successful because they identify concerns before boards do. Regular shareholder engagement helps companies identify emerging concerns so that they can be addressed before positions become entrenched. Such engagement also gives investors opportunities to understand the board’s reasoning and raise questions about strategy, performance or governance. Responsiveness can be an important consideration for institutional shareholders assessing a contested situation.

5. Rehearse the response

An activism response exercise can test the same organisational readiness that boards review for cyber incidents, operational disruption and other crises.

The exercise can establish who would lead the response, which advisors would be involved, how communications would be managed and what information would be needed.

Preparation does not eliminate risk, however. It helps boards identify gaps and coordinate their response under pressure.

Preparation starts before a public campaign

Activism continues to evolve in the UK. Whether it emerges through a public campaign, an M&A transaction or a challenge to board composition, shareholders are demonstrating a greater willingness to make their views known.

Most activist situations do not begin with a proxy fight. They begin with shareholder concerns that are visible long before a campaign becomes public.

Boards that understand their investors, monitor voting behaviour and maintain open dialogue as well as prepare for potential challenges are better positioned to retain credibility, maintain support and respond effectively when pressure arrives.

The practical question is not just whether a company could face activism. It is whether the board has the information, relationships and response plan to address a challenge when it arrives.

*the views expressed are the author's and not ICAEW's
Open AddCPD icon