ICAEW.com works better with JavaScript enabled.

ICAEW KNOW HOW

Loans at non-market rates under FRS 102

Helpsheets and support

Published: 11 Jul 2017 Updated: 06 Jul 2022 Update History

This short guide outlines, and illustrates by example, the accounting requirements of FRS 102 The Financial Reporting Standard applicable in the UK and Republic of Ireland applicable to loans that are provided interest free or at below-market interest rates, a common example of which are intercompany loans.

This ICAEW Know-How was created by the Corporate Reporting Faculty.

FRS 102 accounting requirements

Most straightforward loans, including those with a fixed or determinable repayment date and a positive fixed or variable interest rate, are classified as basic financial instruments under FRS 102. In most cases, basic financial instruments are initially measured at the transaction price (including transaction costs) and subsequently measured at amortised cost, using the effective interest rate method.

However, if an arrangement constitutes a financing transaction, paragraph 11.13 of FRS 102 requires the initial measurement to be at the present value of the future payments (including interest payments and repayment of the principal), discounted at a market rate of interest for a similar debt instrument, adjusted for transaction costs. An arrangement constitutes a financing transaction if payment is deferred beyond normal business terms or is financed at a rate of interest that is not a market rate. Loans provided interest free or at below-market interest rates will therefore constitute a financing transaction and be subject to the above requirements. Intercompany loans and loans between an entity and its directors are common examples of such loans in practice.

Paragraph 11.13A) does, however, include an exception that allows some financing transactions to be measured initially at transaction price. Importantly, this exception applies to a basic financial liability of a small entity that is a loan from a person who is within a director’s group of close family members, when that group contains at least one shareholder in the entity. This exemption does not apply to intra-group loans.

The application of the standard will mean that loans with a fixed or determinable repayment date that have been provided interest free or at a below-market rate of interest will be initially recorded at less than the face value of the loan. FRS 102 does not set out specific requirements for how to account for the difference between the face value of the loan and the amount initially recognised; an entity should apply judgement to select an accounting policy that results in relevant and reliable information in accordance with FRS 102 paragraph 10.4. The individual facts and circumstances in each case should be considered, including the reason(s) the lender decided to make the loan at a non-market rate of interest.

Intercompany loans

In the case of intercompany loans, the loan is often made at a non-market rate of interest because the parent controls its subsidiary and is acting in its capacity as owner. How the difference between the face value of the loan and the amount initially recognised is accounted for depends on the circumstances of the loan:

  • If the loan is from the parent to the subsidiary, the difference is effectively an additional investment in the subsidiary (the borrower) by the parent (the lender); in turn, the subsidiary is effectively receiving an additional capital contribution from its parent.
  • If the loan was from a subsidiary to the parent, the difference will generally be accounted for as a distribution by the subsidiary. Many companies do not realise it, but this is legally a distribution. The subsidiary would therefore need to ensure that it had sufficient distributable reserves for the transaction to be permitted.
  • For loans between subsidiaries, assuming they are made at the behest of the parent, the difference would typically be accounted for as a distribution by the lender and a capital contribution by the borrower. No entries are generally necessary in the parent’s accounts.

Although most loans with a fixed or determinable repayment date and which are provided interest free or at below-market interest rates will meet the criteria to be classified as basic financial instruments, this classification should not be assumed without a thorough analysis of all contractual terms. If a loan fails to qualify as basic, it will be measured at fair value at each reporting date, with movements recognised in profit or loss.

Example

On 1 January 20X1, a parent company lends its subsidiary £5m at a zero rate of interest. The loan is repayable on 31 December 20X4. The market rate of interest for a similar debt instrument is 3%.
On 1 January 20X1, the subsidiary initially measures the loan at the present value of £5m payable in four years, discounted at 3% being the market rate of interest for a similar debt instrument ie, £5m/1.03 = £4,442,435. The loan is subsequently accounted for as follows:

Year

Carrying amount at beginning of period
£

Interest expense at 3%
£

Cash outflow
£

Carrying amount at end of period
£

20X1

4,442,435

133,273

0

4,575,708

20X2

4,575,708 137,271

0

4,712,979

20X3

4,712,979 141,389

0

4,854,368

20X4

4,854,368 145,632

(5,000,000)

-

In this example, where the loan is from the parent to the subsidiary, the difference between the face value of the loan and the amount initially recognised, being £557,565 (£5,000,000 less £4,442,435), will generally be accounted for by the subsidiary as a capital contribution from its parent.

The double entries recorded by the parent and the subsidiary in their individual financial statements are below.

Parent accounts

Dr Loan receivable

£4,442,435

 

Dr Investment in subsidiary1

£557,565

Cr Cash at bank

 

£5,000,000

being initial recognition of loan

 

Dr Loan receivable

£133,273

 

Cr Profit or loss – interest income2

 

£133,273

being application of amortised cost method in 20X1, with similar entries in 20X2 to 20X4

 

Dr Cash at bank

£5,000,000

 

Cr Loan receivable

 

£5,000,000

being repayment of loan

[1] The investment in the subsidiary will be subject to impairment testing if there are indications of impairment.

[2] The interest income will be considered realised if there is reasonable certainty that the balance can be repaid at maturity and an expectation that it will be settled without a replacement loan being advanced (Tech 02/17BL 9.51 and 9.57).

Subsidiary accounts

Dr Cash at bank

£5,000,000

 

Cr Loan payable

  £4,442,435

Cr Capital contribution – equity3

 

£557,565

being initial recognition of loan

 

Dr Profit or loss – interest expense3

£133,273

 

Cr Loan payable

 

£133,273

being application of amortised cost method in 20X1, with similar entries in 20X2 to 20X4

 

Dr Loan payable

£5,000,000

 

Cr Cash at bank

 

£5,000,000

being repayment of loan

[3] The credit to equity in the subsidiary and the interest expense are not considered to be a realised profit or loss (Tech 02/17BL 9.51 and 9.53-54). This capital contribution could be taken to either retained profits or another separate component of equity. When it is taken to a separate component of equity, entities may wish to make an annual transfer from this reserve to the P&L reserve of an amount equal to the interest expense recognised under the amortised cost method. However, this transfer is not required by FRS 102.

The appendix below illustrates how this loan might be accounted for if it was from a subsidiary to its parent or between two subsidiaries at the behest of their parent.

Loans with rolling notice periods

Where a parent provides a loan to a subsidiary at a below market rate with an agreed rolling notice period of a year or more, the initial accounting treatment is the same as in the example above with the period over which the loan repayment value is discounted being the length of the notice period. The carrying value will remain at the amount initially recognised until notice is given, at which point interest will start to accrue over the notice period. Discounting may not be required if the amounts involved are immaterial, which may be the case if the rolling notice period is for one year.

Loans that are repayable on demand

A loan is considered ‘repayable on demand’ if the lender can demand repayment at any time.4

An intercompany loan that is repayable on demand must be recognised at the undiscounted cash amount required to settle the obligation and would need to be shown as a current liability. Such a loan would not meet the criteria for a financing transaction as described above.

Letters of support

Sometimes a parent will issue a letter of support stating that it will not demand repayment of a loan within a specified period (often the following financial reporting year). In most instances, a letter of support is merely an expression of the parent’s intention. In other words, it is not a binding legal document. Where this is the case, a letter of support will not alter the accounting treatment.

[4] An interest-free loan which is legally repayable on demand may be a distribution as a matter of law if the counterparty has no practical ability to repay the loan in the foreseeable future. There will be no distribution as a matter of law if the borrower is practicably able to repay on demand even if it has no intention to do so. A subsidiary cannot lawfully enter into a transaction involving it making a distribution unless the amount of the distribution as a matter of law is covered by distributable reserves. See Tech 02/17BL 9.67-68 for more details.

Loans between an entity and its directors

Interest-free loans may also be made between an entity and one or more of its directors. How the difference between the face value of such loans and the amount initially recognised is accounted for will depend on whether the loan was made in the director’s capacity as a shareholder or for another reason.

If a director acting in their capacity as a shareholder provides or receives a fixed term interest-free loan, the measurement difference is accounted for in a manner similar where there is a loan between a parent and its subsidiary as illustrated above ie, it is treated as a capital contribution if the loan is made by the director to the entity and as distribution if the loan is made by the entity to the director. It can generally be presumed5 that the loan was made in the director’s capacity as a shareholder if a director is the majority shareholder.

A director who is not acting in their capacity as a shareholder or who has no direct ownership interest in the entity may also provide the entity with an interest-free loan. The appropriate accounting treatment will depend on the individual circumstances of each transaction.

If an entity provides an interest-free loan to a director who is not acting in their capacity as a shareholder or who has no direct ownership interest in the entity, the terms of the loan and the reasons for making it will need to be carefully assessed to determine the appropriate accounting treatment. Often such loans will be made for a specific purpose, such as purchasing a season ticket. In such circumstances, the entity should account for the measurement difference as an employee benefit in accordance with Section 28 of FRS 102.

[5] This presumption can be rebutted where, for example, loans between the entity and other third parties without an ownership interest in the entity (eg, employees) are made on the same or similar terms.

Loans between related parties owned and controlled by the same person

Sometimes an interest-free loan will be made between entities that are not members of the same group, but that are related parties because they are owned and controlled by the same person. The accounting for such loans will be the same for an interest-free loan between fellow subsidiaries unless the facts and circumstances indicate that the loan has been provided interest-free for a reason other than that the entities are controlled by the same owner.

Further resources

Further resources on FRS 102 The Financial Reporting Standard applicable in the UK and Republic of Ireland are accessible at icaew.com/frs102.

For more guidance on the requirements of IFRS and UK GAAP visit icaew.com/financialreporting

ICAEW members, affiliates, ICAEW students and staff in eligible firms with member firm access can discuss their specific situation with the Technical Advisory Service on +44 (0)1908 248250 or via live web chat.

Appendix

Loan from subsidiary to parent

Parent accounts

Dr Cash at bank

£5,000,000

 

Cr Loan payable

  £4,442,435

Cr Profit or loss – income from subsidiary6

 

£557,565

being initial recognition of loan

 

Dr Profit or loss – interest expense6

£133,273

 

Cr Loan payable

 

£133,273

being application of amortised cost method in 20X1, with similar entries in 20X2 to 20X4

 

Dr Loan payable

£5,000,000

 

Cr Cash at bank

 

£5,000,000

being repayment of loan

[6] The distribution from the subsidiary to the parent and the interest expense/income are generally considered to be realised on the assumption that the loan has been entered into for genuine business purposes (Tech 02/17BL 9.61).

Subsidiary accounts

Dr Loan receivable

£4,442,435

 

Dr Distribution – equity6

£557,565

 

Cr Cash at bank

 

£5,000,000

being initial recognition of loan

 

Dr Loan receivable

£133,273

 

Cr Profit or loss – interest income6

 

£133,273

being application of amortised cost method in 20X1, with similar entries in 20X2 to 20X4

 

Dr Cash at bank

£5,000,000

 

Cr Loan receivable

 

£5,000,000

being repayment of loan

[6] The distribution from the subsidiary to the parent and the interest expense/income are generally considered to be realised on the assumption that the loan has been entered into for genuine business purposes (Tech 02/17BL 9.61).

Loan from subsidiary to subsidiary

Borrower's accounts

Dr Cash at bank

£5,000,000

 

Cr Loan payable

 

£4,442,435

Cr Capital contribution – equity7

 

£557,565

being initial recognition of loan

 

Dr Profit or loss – interest expense7

£133,273

 
Cr Loan payable

 

 

£133,273

being application of amortised cost method in 20X1, with similar entries in 20X2 to 20X4

 

Dr Loan payable

£5,000,000

 

Cr Cash at bank

 

£5,000,000

being repayment of loan

[7]  The credit to equity in the borrower and the interest expense are not considered to be a realised profit or loss (Tech 02/17BL 9.65). The capital contribution could be taken to either retained profits or another separate component of equity. When it is taken to a separate component of equity, entities may wish to make an annual transfer from this reserve to the P&L reserve of an amount equal to the interest expense recognised under the amortised cost method. However, this transfer is not required by the FRS 102.

Lender's accounts

Dr Loan receivable

£4,442,435

 

Dr Distribution – equity8

£557,565

 

Cr Cash at bank

 

£5,000,000

being initial recognition of loan

 

Dr Loan receivable

£133,273

 
Cr Profit or loss – interest income8

 

£133,273

being application of amortised cost method in 20X1, with similar entries in 20X2 to 20X4

 

Dr Cash at bank

£5,000,000

 

Cr Loan receivable

 

£5,000,000

being repayment of loan

[8}  The distribution and the interest receivable are generally considered to be realised on the assumption that the loan has been entered into for genuine business purposes (Tech 02/17BL 9.61-9.62).

Parent accounts

No entries are generally necessary

ICAEW Know-How from the Corporate Reporting Faculty

This guidance is created by the Corporate Reporting Faculty – recognised internationally as a leading authority on financial reporting. The Faculty formulates ICAEW policy on financial reporting issues and makes submissions to standard setters and other external bodies. Join the Faculty to access exclusive technical resources and practical know-how.

Corporate Reporting Faculty ident lighthouse
Download guide

Outlines requirements of FRS 102 applicable to loans at non-market rates.

Download now
Open AddCPD icon

Add Verified CPD Activity

Introducing AddCPD, a new way to record your CPD activities!

Log in to start using the AddCPD tool. Available only to ICAEW members.

Add this page to your CPD activity

Step 1 of 3
Download recorded
Download not recorded

Please download the related document if you wish to add this activity to your record

What time are you claiming for this activity?
Mandatory fields

Add this page to your CPD activity

Step 2 of 3
Mandatory field

Add activity to my record

Step 3 of 3
Mandatory field

Activity added

An error has occurred
Please try again

If the problem persists please contact our helpline on +44 (0)1908 248 250