ICAEW.com works better with JavaScript enabled.

The 2014 case of Arbuthnott v Bonnyman and Ors

This is a case involving a private equity business, Charterhouse Capital Limited. The case was brought by a dissident shareholder and former executive at Charterhouse, Mr Arbuthnott, under the provisions of Section 994, Companies Act 2006.

In the period following a buyout of the business in 2001 several of the founder shareholders had retired but had retained their shareholdings. This meant that there was an increasing misalignment of the management and ownership interests. However their close alignment was considered to be essential by various investors and was a core part of the business model of the company. 

At the heart of this case was an offer made for the shares of Charterhouse by a company set up by management for the purpose. Watling Street Limited. All the outgoing shareholders accepted the offer of £15.15 million in cash and loan notes for the entire share capital of the company apart from Mr Arbuthnott. 


Continue reading

This content is not freely available. To access 'The 2014 case of Arbuthnott v Bonnyman and Ors' you need to be one of the following:

ACA student

This content is available to ACA students. If you want to start the ACA qualification there are several routes you can take

Business and Finance Professional

An internationally recognised designation and professional status from the ICAEW.

ICAEW member

Gain access to world-leading information resources, guidance and local networks. 98% of the best global brands rely on ICAEW chartered accountants.

Valuation Community

Expert insights into regulatory and technical changes impacting this increasingly complex field.