ICAEW.com works better with JavaScript enabled.

Chart of the week: a new debt target?

Author: ICAEW Insights

Published: 17 Oct 2024

Our chart this week takes a look at how the debt target in the Autumn Budget later this month could change and what that might mean for the Chancellor’s capacity to borrow to invest.
cotw 17 oct

The Autumn Budget is later this month and our focus this week is on taxation and the scope the Chancellor has to raise more in taxes. This follows our shallow dive into public spending last week.

We start with the position set out by then Chancellor Jeremy Hunt in the Spring Budget 2024 in March, which budgeted for total receipts of £1,139bn in the current financial year. As our chart this week illustrates, the top five taxes are forecast to generate £776bn or 68% of total receipts and the next 10 taxes are expected to generate £182bn or 16% of total. Together these 15 taxes should generate £958bn or 84% of the total. Overall, this is still £87bn short of planned public spending of £1,226bn this year. 

Income tax generates the most with a forecast of £303bn for the current financial year, followed by £203bn from VAT, £113bn from employer national insurance, £101bn from corporation tax, and £56bn from employee (and self-employee) national insurance contributions.

Council taxes are expected to provide £47bn, followed by £32bn from business rates, £25bn from fuel duties, £15bn from capital gains tax, £14bn from stamp duty on properties (land and buildings transactions tax in Scotland and land transactions tax in Wales), £13bn from alcohol duties, £11bn from environmental levies, £9bn from tobacco duties, £8bn from vehicle excise duty, and £8bn from insurance premium tax (IPT). 

Not shown on the chart is inheritance tax, which at 16 in the list of taxes is expected to generate £7.5bn in 2024/25.

The game theory that was played out during the general election led both main parties to promise not to raise the main rates of taxation – income tax, VAT, corporation tax, and employee and self-employee national insurance. With these constituting four out of the five biggest taxes as illustrated by our chart, this severely restricts the ability of the Chancellor to find the £20bn to £30bn in additional tax revenues that the Institute for Fiscal Studies believe she needs to maintain day-to-day public spending at its current levels. 

HMRC estimates that putting an extra penny on the basic rate of income tax should produce around £6bn a year in additional tax revenue, while increasing the rate of fuel duty on petrol and diesel by 1% would raise only £260m.

Officially, her commitment is not to put up the basic income tax rate of 20%, the VAT standard rate of 20%, the main corporation tax rate of 25%, or the main rates of national insurance of 8% for employees and 6% for the self-employed. However, the government has also said that they do not intend to increase taxes on working people, a rather ambiguous term that depends on how you define ‘working people’, and what constitutes a tax on them.

There is still some scope to increase some of these bigger taxes given that the government’s commitments do not cover some of the other rates in these taxes, such as the 40% higher and 45% top rates of income tax, the 19% small profits rate for corporation tax, and the 2% rate of employee and self-employee national insurance on higher salaries or earnings. It also does not cover the 5% reduced rate of VAT on domestic energy supplies or the zero rate on food for example, although these are probably caught by the ‘taxes on working people’ language.

The one major tax rate not covered by the government’s tax commitments is the 13.8% main rate of employer national insurance, and the Prime Minister has refused to confirm or deny whether this could change in the upcoming Autumn Budget. Despite that, most of the pre-Budget speculation has been focused on tax reliefs, such as the potential to restrict one or more of the different reliefs currently given on pension contributions or the tax treatment of ‘non-doms’.

With council tax and business rate increases over the next few years already pencilled in by the previous government, the next biggest tax to go looking for money is fuel duty, which has been repeatedly frozen over the last decade or so. There has also been speculation about raising more money from capital gain tax and inheritance tax, which admittedly could end up promoting the latter into the top 15,

Successive chancellors have adopted an ‘every little helps’ philosophy of finding the money they need from a series of relatively small changes to the tax system, and this Chancellor is likely to be no different. 

Unfortunately, the consequence is ever more complexity in the tax system rather than the simplification that successive governments have officially said that they are in favour of.

Latest charts

Further resources

ICAEW Community
Public Sector polaroid
Public Sector Community

The go-to place for guidance on issues affecting finance professionals working in and with the public sector. With a range of dynamic services, ICAEW provides valuable tools, resources and support tailored to the public sector.

Analysis
Analysis from ICAEW's experts on the Autumn Budget 2021 and the comprehensive spending review published on 27 October 2021.
Budget 2024

On 30 October 2024, Rachel Reeves will deliver the government's first Budget. Read ICAEW's recommendations to government and keep up to date with the latest developments.

Read more ICAEW's Budget Submission
ICAEW support
A group of people in a meeting room with their laptops, woman at the whiteboard with sticky notes
Training and events

Browse upcoming and on-demand ICAEW events and webinars offering support on technical areas, such as assurance, reporting and tax, as well as personal development.

See what's coming up A-Z of CPD courses
Open AddCPD icon

Add Verified CPD Activity

Introducing AddCPD, a new way to record your CPD activities!

Log in to start using the AddCPD tool. Available only to ICAEW members.

Add this page to your CPD activity

Step 1 of 3
Download recorded
Download not recorded

Please download the related document if you wish to add this activity to your record

What time are you claiming for this activity?
Mandatory fields

Add this page to your CPD activity

Step 2 of 3
Mandatory field

Add activity to my record

Step 3 of 3
Mandatory field

Activity added

An error has occurred
Please try again

If the problem persists please contact our helpline on +44 (0)1908 248 250