ICAEW.com works better with JavaScript enabled.

John Belcher: architecture and the unity of the arts

A look at the life and work of John Belcher, designer of the original Chartered Accountants’ Hall building which opened in 1893.

John Belcher (1841–1913) brought architecture, sculpture and painting together in some of the most distinctive buildings of his age. Chartered Accountants’ Hall stands as a lasting expression of this approach.
Here, we track the course of his accomplished career, of which Chartered Accountants’ Hall forms the centrepiece.
John Belcher as depicted by Hamo Thornycroft, on the exterior of Chartered Accountants' Hall.
John Belcher as depicted by Hamo Thornycroft, on the exterior of Chartered Accountants' Hall. Image source: Courtauld Institute of Art. Licensed for reuse under CC BY-NC 4.0. Cropped from original.

Training and early career

Born in Southwark in 1841, Belcher trained with his architect father, also John, and studied in Paris in 1862–63. He joined his father in partnership in 1865, continuing the practice after the elder Belcher retired in 1875.

Perhaps their best-known joint commission was the Gothic building at the junction of Poultry and Queen Victoria Street in London, completed in 1871. Later occupied by Mappin & Webb, it was demolished in 1994 to make way for James Stirling’s No. 1 Poultry. Its pointed arches and steep roofline offer a marked contrast to the Italianate forms of Chartered Accountants’ Hall.

The Mappin & Webb building which formerly stood at the junction of Poultry and Queen Victoria Street in London.
The Mappin & Webb building which formerly stood at the junction of Poultry and Queen Victoria Street in London. Its design was attributed to the family practice, J. & J. Belcher. Photograph © Copyright Derek Voller and licensed for reuse under CC BY-SA 2.0.
Over time, the younger Belcher became increasingly interested in Italian Renaissance architecture, particularly the palaces of Genoa. Their combination of classical forms and sculptural ornament offered an approach suited to his artistic interests.

Chartered Accountants’ Hall — a case study in the alliance of the arts

In 1888, Belcher was one of six architects invited to compete for the commission to design ICAEW’s headquarters, with Alfred Waterhouse — then President of the Royal Institute of British Architects (RIBA) — being appointed as the competition’s “professional assessor”.

Ultimately, Belcher’s richly modelled neo-Baroque design — intended, in his words, to “express a proper stateliness and dignity befitting a public institution” — was chosen as the winner, with the Building Committee Minutes of 11 December recording that it was “the one most suitable for the purposes of the Institute”. Construction followed in 1890–93.

The front elevation of Chartered Accountants’ Hall, as drawn by John Belcher.
A drawing by Belcher showing his design for the front elevation of Chartered Accountants' Hall, as reproduced in The Builder, 12 January 1889. It differs in some respects from the finished building. For instance, it shows a freestanding sculpted figure standing atop the projecting bay above the main entrance.

Belcher’s approach to the project reflected his strong commitment to the Art Workers’ Guild’s creed of ‘unity of the arts’; indeed, he had chaired the Guild’s inaugural meeting in 1884. As such, he was closely involved in every aspect of the exterior and interior design, assisted by fellow architect Arthur Beresford Pite. He commented on one occasion that every detail was worked out by himself, and committee papers in the ICAEW archives show that he was still involved in decisions about interior decoration many years after the building's completion.

Sculpture, in particular, was integral to the building’s design. In a lecture given at RIBA in 1892, Belcher emphasised the importance of engaging with the sculptor at the outset of any architectural project, thus enabling him to “to give expression to the purpose and object of the building, to emphasise its character, and animate it with life and beauty”. In this case there were two sculptors — Hamo Thornycroft, whose frieze depicts activities benefiting from accountancy, and Harry Bates, whose figures animate the lower façade.

The Great Swan Alley front of Chartered Accountants’ Hall, as seen in 1893.
The Great Swan Alley façade of Chartered Accountants’ Hall, adorned with sculpture by Hamo Thornycroft and Harry Bates, photographed in 1893. The niche over the recessed doorway was originally intended to house a seated bronze statue of Queen Victoria, but this plan was never realised.
Painting, too, formed an important part of Belcher’s artistic ambitions for the Hall. He always intended the Council Chamber (now the Main Reception Room) to contain murals, but early designs prepared by the Scottish artist William Mouat Loudan — including a scene from The Merchant of Venice — were never executed. He later turned to George Murray, whose paintings depicting the Triumph of Law and Science bringing Order to Commerce were carried out in a Raphaelesque manner in 1913–14. Sadly, Belcher did not live to see them finished.
ICAEW council chamber, photographed 1936
The Council Chamber (now the Main Reception Room), with its paintings by George Murray, photographed in 1936.

The overall success of Belcher’s endeavour is reflected in the widespread praise the building has received. Writing in 1895, Reginald Blomfield described it as “the most remarkable and successful instance of the combination of architecture and sculpture carried out in England this century”. Later, the Dictionary of National Biography noted that the Hall “at once made [Belcher’s] fame, and became a landmark in City architecture”. In his Buildings of England series, Pevsner described it as “eminently original and delightfully picturesque”.

Keith Macdonald and Sam McKinstry have interpreted the Hall as an assertion of professional standing on the part of the fledgling ICAEW, comparable to the headquarters of established legal and medical bodies. This reading is supported by the 5 August 1890 issue of The Accountant, in which the magazine’s editor describes the building as “the actual and visible embodiment of the astonishing growth of a profession, young but already of commanding power, and capable of almost unlimited extension”.

Belcher’s angels — symbols of the Second Coming?

Belcher’s religious life offers another perspective on his work at Chartered Accountants’ Hall and elsewhere. He belonged to the Catholic Apostolic Church, which emerged in the 1830s and anticipated Christ’s return during the lifetimes of its twelve Apostles (founding fathers). From 1908 until his death, he served as an ‘Angel’ — a senior minister — at its church in Camberwell.

Writing in the Victorian Society Journal, Tony Wilson has interpreted the angels and lions which are recurring motifs in Belcher’s work as expressions of these religious beliefs. According to this reading, the seven angels which adorn Chartered Accountants’ Hall’s Moorgate Place façade symbolise the seven trumpeting angels from the Book of Revelation. These, along with the five angels originally on the Great Swan Alley front (before the later extensions) made twelve in total — a number apparently intended to evoke the coming of the New Jerusalem, with its twelve gates, each guarded by an angel.

Picture of angel statues on the outside of the building
Two of the seven original angels on the Moorgate Place façade. There are four to the left of the entrance and 3 to the right.
Whether Belcher intended them to be interpreted this way or not, angels have remained part of the building’s identity as it has evolved over time: the 1930s extension added several more (this time with contemporary bobbed hairstyles), and yet more were added during the 1960s–70s enlargement.

Colchester Town Hall — civic identity in stone

With his work at Chartered Accountants’ Hall having established Belcher as a leading architect of his generation, further major commissions followed.

At Colchester Town Hall, opened in 1902, Belcher applied his elaborate classical vocabulary to a municipal commission. Red brick and Portland stone, tall Corinthian columns and a richly ornamented tower give the building a commanding presence on the High Street.

Colchester Town Hall, a large building in free classical style, built in red brick and Portland stone.
Belcher's Grade I listed Colchester Town Hall, opened in 1902. Photograph © Copyright Keith Edkins and licensed for reuse under CC BY-SA 2.0.
As at Chartered Accountants’ Hall, sculpture communicates institutional identity: the tower carries figures representing fishing, engineering, military defence and agriculture, with St. Helena (Colchester's patron saint) at its summit. This expression of local history and economic life accords with Belcher’s argument that a building should convey a message appropriate to its purpose.

Electra House — communicating corporate ambition

A short walk from Chartered Accountants’ Hall, Electra House offers a further example of Belcher’s approach to institutional image. Built in 1900–03 with John James Joass (who joined Belcher’s office in the late 1890s and later became a partner) it originally accommodated the Eastern Telegraph Company. Its giant columns, curved colonnade and central dome brought considerable grandeur to an office building.
Electra House, Moorgate, London, showing its ornate stone façade, tall columns, arched entrance and central dome crowned by a bronze globe.
Electra House on Moorgate in London. Photograph © Copyright Ramillies and licensed for reuse under CC BY-SA 3.0.
Here, architecture and art are combined once again in the creation of a united whole — one which speaks both of its purpose and of the client’s ambitions. Sculpture by George Frampton, Alfred Drury, F. W. Pomeroy and William Goscombe John incorporates references to telegraphy, commerce and overseas territories into the façade. Inside, George Murray’s mural continued the theme, depicting connections between countries through the cable network.

The Ashton Memorial — a landmark in the landscape

Completed in 1909, the Ashton Memorial in Lancaster gave Belcher and Joass the opportunity to design a freestanding monument in an expansive parkland setting. Commissioned by the industrialist Lord Ashton to commemorate his family, and particularly associated with his late wife, Jessy, it stands at the highest point in Williamson Park, its copper-clad dome rising above the city.

The Ashton Memorial in Lancaster, as viewed from below.
Belcher and Joass's Ashton Memorial in Lancaster, as seen from below.

The memorial was the centrepiece of a wider programme of improvements to the park, funded by Lord Ashton. For the crescent-shaped ornamental lake, Belcher and Joass designed a fountain and a balustraded stone footbridge to replace an earlier timber crossing. On a rocky rise overlooking the water stood their garden pavilion, known as the Temple Shelter. Closer to the memorial, the architects designed a palm house, now the park’s Butterfly House.

The fountain (left) and Temple Shelter (right) in Williamson Park, Lancaster.
The ornamental lake fountain (left) and Temple Shelter (right) in Williamson Park, Lancaster. Both were designed by Belcher and Joass. Photograph of the Temple Shelter © Copyright Karl and Ali and licensed for reuse under CC BY-SA 2.0.

Around the memorial’s dome, allegorical figures by Herbert Hampton and, inside, paintings by George Murray continue the collaboration between architecture and the decorative arts seen throughout Belcher’s work. The open setting offers a striking contrast to the confined City site of Chartered Accountants’ Hall, allowing the monument to be appreciated from afar as well as close at hand — a distinction that accords with Belcher’s emphasis on surroundings, scale and viewing distance.

The interior of the Ashton Memorial in Lancaster.
The lower domed chamber of the Ashton Memorial, decorated with allegorical paintings by George Murray. Murray also produced paintings for the Council Chamber (now the Main Reception Room) at Chartered Accountants’ Hall.

Later career and legacy

In the later part of Belcher’s career, it was his partner Joass who increasingly took the lead in the practice’s design work. Commissions undertaken by the practice during Belcher’s final years included Whiteley's department store and the Royal Society of Medicine.

During this period, Belcher set about codifying the foundational principles of his approach to architecture. The product of this endeavour was a well-received book of essays, Essentials in Architecture, published in 1907. In it, Belcher argued — among other things — that buildings should truthfully express their purpose and construction, with sculpture and carefully-considered ornament contributing to a coherent whole. Its discussions of scale, light and shade offer a useful perspective on Chartered Accountants’ Hall, where carefully placed sculpture and deeply modelled details give richness and emphasis to a building on a confined City site.

His professional standing was recognised by his election as RIBA president (1904–06), the award of its Royal Gold Medal in 1907 and election as a Royal Academician in 1909. Outside of architecture, he was an accomplished bass singer, cellist and conductor.

Belcher died on 8 November 1913. Chartered Accountants’ Hall stands to this day as a lasting expression of his belief in the collaboration of the arts, and the defining achievement of his career.

Can't find what you're looking for?

The ICAEW Library can give you the right information from trustworthy, professional sources that aren't freely available online. Contact us for expert help with your enquiries and research.

Disclaimer

ICAEW accepts no responsibility for the content on any site to which a hypertext link from this site exists. The links are provided ‘as is’ with no warranty, express or implied, for the information provided within them. Please see the full copyright and disclaimer notice.

Learn more about Chartered Accountants’ Hall

The Library team has produced a history and overview of Chartered Accountants' Hall, home to ICAEW since 1893.

Browse resources